home
on exploration, introspection and creation

Rhetorical questions in advertisements

I saw some charity’s ad the other day (I’m still struggling with the idea of charities doing advertising — something just doesn’t seem right with that, even though intellectually I know that it is a very sensible thing). “If you could improve a life, would you?”

I have a big issue with the fact that the question has a tautological premise (since everyone can improve lives, that’s precisely the premise of the majority of charities out there) which gives me no insight into why I should give into this particular charity. The best proof for this is, well, that I forgot which charity this was an ad for…

How about a counter-ad. “If you could ask a meaningless question, would you?”

Leave a Reply